Aerial view of the National Security Agency headquarters buildings and car parks at Fort Meade, MarylandFile photo: The National Security Agency headquarters at Fort Meade, Maryland. Photo: National Security Agency via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

An Anthropic AI model has explained where the unexplained numbers behind the NIST P-256 curve and its siblings came from: an ordinary random number generator started from a computer clock in 1997 and 1998. Cryptographers who checked the result say it all but rules out the long-rumoured NSA backdoor.

By HahuPrime News Desk | October 18, 2026

SAN FRANCISCO — At 01:52:34 UTC on August 16, 1997, someone started a random number generator on a computer and let it run. The 1,842nd string of numbers it produced became one of the most important constants in modern cryptography, the “seed” behind the NIST P-256 curve that protects a large share of the world’s secure web traffic.

Nobody knew that until this week. On Friday, October 16, Anthropic said an internal research version of its Claude model had worked out, in under half an hour, how the NIST curve seeds were generated. The puzzle had stood for more than 25 years.

Key points

  • The seeds of the NIST curves P-192, P-224, P-256, P-384 and P-521 came from the old C library generator lrand48, started with Unix timestamps from May 1997 to April 1998.
  • Anthropic says its model found the method in under 30 minutes; outside cryptographers have reproduced the result.
  • It is not a break or a new weakness. Users do not need to do anything.
  • A $36,864 bounty for the answer has gone to the non-profit behind Let’s Encrypt.

The curves are a set of fixed mathematical parameters published by the US National Institute of Standards and Technology in 2000 for the ECDSA digital signature standard. Part of each curve was derived from a 20-byte seed supplied by the National Security Agency, with no explanation. For two decades that gap fed suspicion that the agency had picked the numbers to plant a weakness only it could exploit.

The best explanation on record came from Jerry Solinas, a longtime NSA mathematician, who said in 2015 that the seeds were hashes of a joke phrase. “The message was along the lines of ‘Give Bob and Jerry a raise’ or ‘Bob and Jerry rule’ or something like that,” he recalled, adding that any archives were “no doubt sitting on a hard drive near the Ark of the Covenant.” Solinas died in 2023.

How the NIST curve seeds were found

Several Anthropic staff had chased the joke phrase and failed, the company said. This time an employee asked the model to work out how the seeds were made without pointing it at the rumour. Instead of guessing sentences, it guessed at the software. Random number generators that shipped with 1990s C libraries were weak enough to leave fingerprints, so it wrote a scanner to look for them. In four of the seeds, the top bit of all 20 32-bit words was zero. That would happen by chance about once in 5,810 tries, Anthropic said, and it is a tell-tale sign of lrand48, which hides part of its internal state.

From there it was arithmetic. The model recovered each generator’s internal state, ran it backwards to the moment it was switched on, and found that every starting value for the prime curves was a Unix timestamp, a computer’s count of seconds since 1970, from between May 1997 and April 1998. Anthropic published a log of the model’s reasoning as the result came in:

“Let me be skeptical: am I in some sort of simulated/test environment? … It’s verified by direct computation on my side … Wow, it’s a real discovery.”

The company’s claim that the work took under 30 minutes cannot be checked from outside. The answer itself can. Anthropic released short code that regenerates the seeds from the timestamps, and when HahuPrime ran it, it produced the P-256 seed exactly as printed in the standard, C49D3608 86E70493 6A6678E1 139D26B7 819F7E90. Filippo Valsorda, the cryptographer who set up a public bounty for the seeds three years ago, said he reimplemented the method himself to verify it.

What it means for the backdoor theory

“We now know how the seeds of the NIST elliptic curves were generated: they’re not the hash of some saucy sentence,” Valsorda wrote on his blog. He said the findings rule out the most serious theory of how a backdoor could have been built, a 2017 idea by cryptographers Daniel Bernstein and Tanja Lange that needed about 70 bits of freedom in choosing the seed. Even if the NSA had been free to pick any timestamp in 1997 and 1998, the agency would have had “barely 30 bits of freedom,” Valsorda wrote, “not enough to embed any kind of NOBUS backdoor”, meaning a weakness that nobody but its maker could use.

The suspicion had history behind it. Documents leaked by Edward Snowden in 2013 were widely reported to show NSA influence over a different NIST standard, the Dual_EC_DRBG random number generator, which NIST later withdrew.

For ordinary users the news is reassuring. P-256 is one of the most widely used curves on the internet, securing many of the connections that banking apps, mobile money and email rely on, from phones in Addis Ababa and Nairobi as much as anywhere. “This is not a cryptographic break, new attack, or weakness in the ECDSA curves,” Anthropic said. “There is no action to be taken.”

It is also another sign of how quickly these AI systems are moving. This week HahuPrime reported that OpenAI models broke into websites to finish tasks and that Anthropic is hiring fewer junior engineers as AI agents take on coding work.

Loose ends remain. The 1997 software skipped some candidates that would have produced valid curves, for reasons nobody can yet explain; for P-256, candidate 876 of the same run also worked. One binary-curve seed, B-163, still fits nothing, and nobody knows how the base points of P-224, P-256, P-384 and P-521 were chosen.

The team gave the bounty to the Internet Security Research Group, which runs the free certificate service Let’s Encrypt, a choice Valsorda said tripled its value to $36,864. He also noted the timing: the curves have been cleared “just in time for them to be retired in favor of post-quantum signatures.”

Sources

68 Views

By HahuPrime News Desk

The HahuPrime News Desk reports on Ethiopia, Eritrea, the Horn of Africa, East Africa, the Red Sea and the Middle East. Our reports separate confirmed facts from claims and analysis, attribute every claim, and list their sources. Corrections: info@hahuprime.com.